Then came the Pearl Harbor attack. Miller’s actions that day would make him a hero. But for months, his identity was not publicly known.
In reports to Navy officials after December 7, men of the West Virginia praised Miller’s bravery. He had “unquestionably [saved] the lives of a number of people who might otherwise have been lost,” wrote the ship’s senior officer. Yet officially, the Navy cited Miller’s actions as those of an unknown Black sailor.
That is, until the Pittsburgh Courier got wind of the story. An influential newspaper for Black Americans, the Courier was pursuing what it called a “Double V campaign”— victory over the Axis powers abroad and over racist policies at home. Its editors believed that publicizing Miller’s identity would be key in the fight for racial equality.
They searched intensely until, in March 1942, the paper uncovered Miller’s name. “ ‘Messman Hero’ Identified,” it announced in a front-page headline. In the next few days, the Courier's story ran in newspapers all over the country.
Public interest in Miller soared. Members of Congress demanded that he be given the Congressional Medal of Honor, the nation’s highest award for bravery in battle. Black leaders echoed the call.
Navy officials resisted, however. Then President Roosevelt and Admiral Chester Nimitz, commander in chief of the Pacific Fleet, stepped in. They were eager to encourage Black Americans to support the war effort and knew acknowledging Miller’s heroism would help. In May 1942, when Miller’s ship made a stopover at Pearl Harbor, Nimitz awarded the young sailor the Navy Cross, the service’s third-highest award. Miller became the first Black American to receive the medal.